Home RSS
Real Estate

Sublease Space Balloons; Office Sales Wither

Paul Bubny Globe St
Sublease Space Balloons; Office Sales Wither - Real Estate - Property - USA - Sublease - Manhattan - Price Drop

Sublease space has come onto the Manhattan office market in quantities that haven’t been seen for years and is putting downward pressure on asking rents, according to several quarterly reports. However, forecasts call for less cloudy conditions as the economy begins to stabilize late this year and into 2010.

"The spread between asking rents and taking rents will start to narrow in the next few months," said John Powers, chairman of the New York tri-state region for CB Richard Ellis, at the company’s quarterly media briefing on Wednesday. In the meantime, though, the availability rate will continue to increase, although Powers predicted it won’t hit the 1992 nationwide peak of 18.7%.

Currently, the overall vacancy rate for Manhattan is 8.5% as measured by CBRE, and reaching 9.6% if the space that will become available in the next months is taken into account, as Cushman & Wakefield does in its first-quarter report. Class A vacancy has reached 10.8% from 10.2% in February, according to the monthly snapshot released Tuesday by Colliers ABR. Midtown’s vacancy rate at 10.5% is noticeably higher than the 8.1% rates seen in both Midtown South and Downtown, according to C&W. "You could almost say this is a Midtown recession," said C&W COO Joseph Harbert during the company’s media briefing on Tuesday.

Some of that increasing availability will result from what Powers called "a lot of shoes dropping" Downtown in the coming months, including the space that Goldman Sachs will give up when it moves into its new headquarters at year’s end and the fallout from AIG’s travails. And some will come from blocks of sublease space as major employers continue to downsize.

Already, the amount of sublet space in Manhattan has more than doubled year over year, reaching 10.3 million square feet at the end of 2009’s first quarter of 2009, up from 4.4 million square feet a year earlier, according to C&W’s Q1 report. That’s the highest amount of available sublease space seen here since the second quarter of 2004, when it reached 10.9 million square feet.

In Midtown, one-third of the 30 million square feet of available space is sublease, Powers said. However, he observed that seven million of the 10 million square feet of sublease space in Midtown is probably unleaseable at present, due to issues with the term structure of the space.

For example, a potential tenant offered a large block of "poorly built-out" space for a two-year sublease would probably pass it up because the expense of build-out for a relatively short stay would not be justified. Conversely, a landlord may be reluctant to make a deal now for a sublease tenant to take over the space in a long-term deal after the existing lease runs out, because it’s difficult to predict what the space will be worth a few years from now.

A lot of that uncertainty about the future stems from what CBRE calls a re-pricing of office space, particularly in Midtown. Overall asking rents for Manhattan fell to $65.01 per square foot in Q1, down 6% or $4.43 decline from $69.44 per square foot at the end of 2008. C&W calls this the largest quarter-over-quarter decline since the company began keeping records in 1984. In Midtown, 11.5 million square feet of office space has seen asking price declines since the Lehman Brothers collapse last September, including 8.2 million square feet in Q1 ’09, according to CBRE. Midtown rents declined 17% in January and in February, and 11% in March. About 30 million square feet has been re-priced downward across Manhattan, CBRE says.


Disclaimer: The information presented and opinions expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Estates Report and/or its partners.